I'm searching for pediatric studies on sleep interventions but finding mostly adult literature. Help me: 1) Use age-specific search filters (Cochrane pediatric filter)

Prompt
I'm searching for pediatric studies on sleep interventions but finding mostly adult literature. Help me: 1) Use age-specific search filters (Cochrane pediatric filter)
ChatGPTOpenAI
I'm searching for pediatric studies on sleep interventions but finding mostly adult literature. Help me: 1) Use age-specific search filters (Cochrane pediatric filter)

Finding pediatric studies on sleep interventions can sometimes be challenging due to the prevalence of adult-focused literature. Here are some strategies you can employ, including using age-specific search filters like the Cochrane Pediatric Filter:

1. Use Age-Specific Search Filters

When searching databases, apply filters specifically designed for pediatric populations. The Cochrane Pediatric Filter and similar filters can help narrow your results. While the actual filter may vary between databases, here’s a generic example of how to adjust your search:

  • Cochrane Library: Use keywords such as "pediatric sleep interventions" and apply filters for children and adolescents.

  • PubMed: You can either rely on MeSH (Medical Subject Headings) terms or use specific age ranges in your search. Use “Child” (age 0-12 years) or “Adolescent” (age 13-18 years) in your queries.

  • CINAHL: Set the age filters to “Child”, “Adolescent”, and “Infant” for more targeted results.


Example Search:
"sleep intervention" AND ("Child"[MeSH] OR "Adolescent"[MeSH] OR "Infant"[MeSH])

2. Search Terms

Make sure you are using appropriate keywords. Here are some suggested search terms:

  • Sleep interventions in children

  • Pediatric sleep disorders

  • Child sleep therapy

  • Behavioral sleep interventions in children

  • Sleep hygiene practices for children


3. Databases

Use specialized databases in addition to general ones:

  • Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Look for systematic reviews related to sleep interventions in children.

  • PubMed: Use the advanced search options to filter studies by age.

  • PsycINFO: For psychological aspects of sleep interventions in children and adolescents.

  • Embase: This database also has a range of pediatric studies, often not covered in PubMed.


4. Recent Reviews

Look for recent systematic reviews or meta-analyses that focus on pediatric sleep interventions. These usually summarize a range of studies and can guide you to specific research.

5. Pediatric Journals

Consider browsing journals specifically focused on pediatrics or child health, such as:

  • Pediatrics

  • Journal of Pediatric Psychology

  • Sleep Medicine Reviews

  • Child and Adolescent Mental Health


6. Consult Libraries/Experts

Reach out to a medical library or a professional in pediatric sleep medicine for help. They might have access to resources or databases not readily available online.

7. Keywords Across Different Studies

Identify keywords and subject headings used in relevant studies you find. Use these to refine your searches.

By combining these strategies, you should be able to find more targeted studies on sleep interventions specifically for pediatric populations. If you need help constructing a specific search or if you want assistance with a particular database, feel free to ask!

{DateTime.UtcNow:HH:mm}
GeminiGoogle
I'm searching for pediatric studies on sleep interventions but finding mostly adult literature. Help me: 1) Use age-specific search filters (Cochrane pediatric filter)

You're running into a common challenge! Pediatric research often gets overshadowed by adult studies, and effective age-specific filtering is key.

Let's break down how to effectively use age-specific filters, especially the Cochrane pediatric filter, and build a robust search strategy for pediatric sleep interventions.


1. Using the Cochrane Pediatric Filter

The "Cochrane pediatric filter" isn't a single clickable button, but rather a pre-defined, validated search strategy (a set of terms and Boolean operators) designed to retrieve studies on children, infants, and adolescents. It combines controlled vocabulary (like MeSH terms) with keywords to maximize sensitivity and specificity for pediatric populations.

Here's how to use it and a common version:

A. How to Use it in the Cochrane Library:

  • Go to the Cochrane Library: https://www.cochranelibrary.com/

  • Navigate to Advanced Search: Look for "Advanced Search" or "Search Manager" on the homepage.

  • Copy and Paste the Pediatric Filter:

You'll enter this into one of the search boxes (often labeled "Add a search term" or similar). This specific filter aims to capture a broad range of pediatric ages.

Common Cochrane Pediatric Search Filter (Example - you might need to adapt slightly for specific databases or if Cochrane has an updated version):

(child OR children OR pediatric OR paediatric OR infant OR infants OR neonate OR neonatal OR newborn OR toddler OR toddlers OR adolescent OR adolescents OR school age OR "school-age" OR "young adult*" OR "juvenile" OR "juveniles" OR "preschool" OR "pre-school" OR "schoolchild" OR "school-child" OR "teenager" OR "teenagers" OR "childhood") OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Child] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Infant] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Adolescent] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Pediatrics] expl)

  • Explanation:

  • OR connects all the different terms for children/age groups, ensuring you catch any of them.

  • (truncation) captures variations (e.g., adolescent gets adolescent, adolescents).

  • "MeSH descriptor": [X] expl uses the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) controlled vocabulary, expanding (expl) to include all narrower terms under "Child," "Infant," "Adolescent," and "Pediatrics." This is highly effective.

  • For the Cochrane Library, the exact syntax for MeSH terms might be [Mesh]Child or similar. The Cochrane database automatically maps many keywords to MeSH, but explicitly using [MeSH descriptor:X] is safer.

  • Combine with Your Intervention/Outcome Terms:

Once you've run the pediatric filter (e.g., as "Search #1"), you'll then combine it with your terms for "sleep intervention" and "sleep outcome" using AND.

Example Steps in Cochrane's Advanced Search:

  • Search 1: (child OR children OR pediatric OR paediatric OR infant OR infants OR neonate OR neonatal OR newborn OR toddler OR toddlers OR adolescent OR adolescents OR school age OR "school-age" OR "young adult*" OR "juvenile" OR "juveniles" OR "preschool" OR "pre-school" OR "schoolchild" OR "school-child" OR "teenager" OR "teenagers" OR "childhood") OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Child] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Infant] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Adolescent] expl) OR ("MeSH descriptor": [Pediatrics] expl)

  • Search 2 (Sleep Intervention Terms): (sleep adj3 (intervent OR therap OR treatment OR program OR education* OR CBT-I OR "cognitive behavioral" OR "behavioral sleep" OR hygiene OR melatonin OR "light therapy" OR "parent training"))

  • Search 3 (Sleep Outcome Terms - Optional, but good for focus): (sleep OR insomnia OR "sleep disorder" OR "sleep quality" OR "sleep duration" OR "sleep latency" OR "night awakenings" OR parasomnia)

  • Search 4 (Final Combination): #1 AND #2 AND #3 (or #1 AND #2 if you find #3 too restrictive initially).


B. Where to Find Official Cochrane Filters:
Cochrane often publishes its specific, up-to-date filters for various topics (including age, study types, etc.) in their methodology chapters or on their website. If you're doing a full systematic review, it's always best to check the latest recommended filters directly from the Cochrane Handbook or their official resources. A quick Google search for "Cochrane pediatric search filter" usually leads to their specific guidance.


2. General Age-Specific Search Filters (Beyond Cochrane)

Most major bibliographic databases offer robust age-specific filtering options.

A. Using Keywords for Age:

This is the simplest starting point and should always be included, as not all studies are perfectly indexed with controlled vocabulary.

  • child* (captures child, children, childhood)

  • pediatric OR paediatric (use both spellings!)

  • infant* (infant, infancy)

  • neonate OR newborn

  • toddler*

  • adolescent OR teen OR juvenile*

  • "school age" OR "school-age"

  • "preschool" OR "pre-school"

  • You can also specify age ranges: "0-18 years" OR "0-12 years" OR "birth-18" etc.


B. Using Controlled Vocabulary (MeSH, Emtree, PsycINFO Thesaurus):

These are powerful and more precise than keywords alone because they map to a standardized concept, regardless of the author's exact phrasing.

  • PubMed (using MeSH - Medical Subject Headings):

  • Go to PubMed.

  • In your search query, use terms like:

  • "Child"[Mesh] (0-18 years)

  • "Infant"[Mesh] (1-23 months)

  • "Infant, Newborn"[Mesh] (0-1 month)

  • "Child, Preschool"[Mesh] (2-5 years)

  • "Child"[Mesh] (6-12 years – note: the "Child" MeSH term covers 6-12 generally, but the broader "Child" entry covers 0-18. It's often best to use the more specific terms or let the "Child"[Mesh] term explode for full coverage)

  • "Adolescent"[Mesh] (13-18 years)

  • Tip: You can often just type child into the PubMed search bar and then use the "Filters" on the left-hand side to select specific age groups (e.g., "Child: 0-18 years," "Infant: 0-23 months," "Adolescent: 13-18 years"). This is often the easiest way in PubMed.

  • Embase (using Emtree):

  • Similar to MeSH, Emtree has specific terms like child, infant, adolescent, newborn. You'll typically search for child/exp (to explode the term and include narrower categories).

  • Embase also has dedicated age filters in its advanced search interface.

  • PsycINFO (using Thesaurus of Psychological Index Terms):

  • Children

  • Infants

  • Adolescents

  • Preschool Age

  • School Age


C. Using Database-Specific Filters:

Most databases have built-in filters usually found on the left-hand sidebar after you perform an initial search.

  • PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, CINAHL, PsycINFO: Look for sections like:

  • Age

  • Patient Age

  • Population

  • Subjects

  • You'll typically see checkboxes or dropdowns for "Child," "Infant," "Adolescent," "Preschooler," "School age," etc.



3. Comprehensive Search Strategy for Pediatric Sleep Interventions

Now let's put it all together into a robust strategy.

A. Core Concepts:

  • Population: Pediatric (as discussed above)

  • Intervention: Sleep interventions

  • Outcome: Sleep (quality, duration, disorders, etc.)


B. Example Search Query Components (Combine with AND):

1. Pediatric Population Terms (Use OR to combine these):

  • (child OR pediatric OR paediatric OR infant OR neonate OR newborn OR toddler OR adolescent OR teen OR juvenile OR "school age" OR "preschool" OR "young adult*")

  • OR "Child"[Mesh] OR "Infant"[Mesh] OR "Adolescent"[Mesh] OR "Child, Preschool"[Mesh] OR "Infant, Newborn"[Mesh] (for PubMed)

  • OR child/exp OR infant/exp OR adolescent/exp OR newborn/exp (for Embase)


2. Sleep Intervention Terms (Use OR to combine these):
  • (sleep adj3 (intervent OR therap OR treatment OR program OR education OR strateg OR counsel OR support OR method OR skill))

  • OR "CBT-I" OR "cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia" OR "behavioral sleep medicine" OR "sleep hygiene" OR "parent training" OR "parent-led intervention" OR "light therapy" OR melatonin OR chronotherapy

  • OR "Sleep Initiation and Maintenance Disorders"[Mesh: noexp] (for PubMed - focuses on insomnia)

  • OR "Cognitive Behavioral Therapy"[Mesh] (for PubMed)

  • OR "Sleep"[Mesh] AND (therapy OR intervention)


3. Sleep Outcome/Condition Terms (Optional, but helps focus; use OR to combine these):
  • (sleep OR insomnia OR "sleep disorder" OR "sleep quality" OR "sleep duration" OR "sleep latency" OR "sleep pattern" OR "night awakenings" OR parasomnia OR "sleep disturbance")

  • OR "Sleep Disorders"[Mesh] (for PubMed)


C. Putting it together in a database (e.g., PubMed):
  • (Pediatric Terms):

("Child"[Mesh] OR "Infant"[Mesh] OR "Adolescent"[Mesh] OR child OR pediatric OR paediatric OR infant OR neonate OR newborn OR toddler OR adolescent OR teen OR juvenile OR "school age" OR "preschool")
  • AND (Intervention Terms):

("sleep initiation and maintenance disorders"[Mesh] OR "sleep disorders"[Mesh] OR "Cognitive Behavioral Therapy"[Mesh] OR (sleep AND (intervent OR therap OR treatment OR program OR education* OR CBT-I OR "cognitive behavioral" OR "behavioral sleep" OR hygiene OR melatonin OR "light therapy" OR "parent training"))
  • AND (Outcome/Condition Terms - if desired, could be combined with intervention):

(sleep OR insomnia OR "sleep quality" OR "sleep duration" OR "sleep latency" OR "sleep pattern" OR "night awakenings" OR parasomnia OR "sleep disturbance*")


Tips for Effective Searching:

  • Start Broad, Then Narrow: Begin with a combination of your key terms, and then use the database's filters (like age, publication type, date range) to refine.

  • Check Reference Lists: Once you find a few highly relevant pediatric studies or reviews, check their reference lists for other good sources.

  • Look for Systematic Reviews: Search for "systematic review" OR "meta-analysis" AND your pediatric and sleep intervention terms. These often provide a great overview and can point you to many primary studies.

  • Test and Iterate: Your first search won't be perfect. Review a sample of results, see what terms they use, and adjust your strategy accordingly.

  • Consult a Librarian: For complex systematic reviews, a research librarian is an invaluable resource for refining search strategies.


By combining specific age terms, controlled vocabulary, and database filters, you should significantly improve your ability to find pediatric sleep intervention studies!

{DateTime.UtcNow:HH:mm}

Analysis

This comparison demonstrates the different approaches each AI model takes when responding to the same prompt. Here are the key differences observed:

Response Characteristics

ChatGPT: Provides a detailed response with 27 sentences.

Gemini: Provides a detailed response with 80 sentences.

Key Takeaways

  • Each model brings unique strengths to this type of query
  • Response styles vary significantly between models
  • Consider your specific use case when choosing between these models

Try This Comparison Yourself

Want to test these models with your own prompts? Visit SNEOS.com to compare AI responses side-by-side in real-time.


This comparison was generated using the SNEOS AI Comparison ToolPublished: October 15, 2025 | Models: ChatGPT, Gemini