I'm creating a registered report. Guide me: 1) Choose journal that accepts registered reports
Choosing a Journal for Your Registered Report
Registered reports are a preregistration format where you submit a study protocol for peer review before data collection, reducing publication bias. Many journals across disciplines accept them, often through platforms like the Center for Open Science (COS). Here's a step-by-step guide to selecting one, followed by recommendations.
Step 1: Identify Your Field and Scope
- Define your discipline: Registered reports are common in psychology, neuroscience, medicine, social sciences, and increasingly in ecology, economics, and humanities. Narrow this down (e.g., clinical psychology vs. cognitive neuroscience) to filter options.
- Check your study's fit: Ensure it aligns with the journal's scope. For example, broad journals suit interdisciplinary work, while specialized ones fit niche topics.
- Consider impact and audience: Aim for journals with your desired readership, but prioritize those committed to open science over high-impact alone.
Step 2: Search for Accepting Journals
- Use directories:
- Registry of Open Science Journals: Go to cos.io (Center for Open Science) and search their list of over 500 journals accepting registered reports. Filter by field (e.g., psychology has 100+ options).
- Open Science Framework (OSF): Search "registered reports" on osf.io for community-curated lists.
- PubMed or Google Scholar: Search "registered report [your topic]" to see where similar studies publish.
- Key criteria to evaluate:
- Acceptance stage: Most review Stage 1 (protocol) before data collection; some require Stage 2 (results) submission later.
- Fees and timelines: Check APCs (article processing charges) for open-access journals; review times vary (e.g., 1-3 months for Stage 1).
- Policies: Look for in-principle acceptance (IPA) to lock in publication if methods are followed.
- Recent examples: Verify they’ve published registered reports in the last 2 years to ensure active support.
Step 3: Recommended Journals by Field
Here are vetted examples from reputable sources like COS (updated as of 2023; always check journal websites for changes). Start with these and expand via searches.
- Psychology/Behavioral Sciences:
- Psychological Science (SAGE): High-impact, broad scope. Accepts across subfields; strong open science emphasis.
- Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (APA): Focuses on fundamental research; IPA common.
- Registered Reports at Collabra: Psychology (UC Press): Dedicated section, open access, low/no fees.
- Neuroscience/Cognitive Science:
- eNeuro (SfN): Free to publish, neuroscience-focused, supports preregistration.
- NeuroImage (Elsevier): Accepts registered reports for imaging studies; hybrid open access.
- Medicine/Clinical Research:
- Trials (BMC): Dedicated to trial protocols; open access, no APC for registered reports in some cases.
- PLOS Medicine (PLOS): Broad health sciences; emphasizes transparency.
- BMJ Open (BMJ): Protocol-focused, with a registered report pathway.
- Social Sciences/Economics:
- Journal of the European Economic Association (Oxford): Economics-specific.
- AEA Papers and Proceedings (American Economic Association): For economic experiments.
- Interdisciplinary/Other:
- Royal Society Open Science: Broad, including biology and ecology; fully open access.
- Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology: Psychology and social sciences, low barriers.
Step 4: Next Steps for Submission
- Review the journal's author guidelines (e.g., under "registered reports" section) for template requirements like hypothesis, analysis plan, and power analysis.
- Prepare your Stage 1 manuscript: Include detailed methods to enable replication.
- If unsure, email the editor with a brief abstract to gauge fit.
- Track progress on OSF for badges and sharing.
This format boosts credibility and reproducibility. If you share your field or topic, I can refine suggestions!
Creating a registered report is a great way to ensure transparency and rigor in your research. Here are the steps to guide you through the process, starting with choosing a journal that accepts registered reports:
1. Choose a Journal that Accepts Registered Reports
Step-by-Step Guide:
- Identify Potential Journals:
- Start by identifying journals in your field of study. Use databases like PubMed, Google Scholar, or your university library's resources to find relevant journals.
- Look for journals that have a strong reputation and are well-regarded in your field.
- Check Journal Policies:
- Visit the websites of the journals you have identified.
- Look for sections such as "Author Guidelines," "Submission Guidelines," or "Instructions for Authors."
- Specifically, search for information on "Registered Reports" or "Pre-registration."
- Review Journal Lists:
- Some organizations and initiatives maintain lists of journals that accept registered reports. For example, the Center for Open Science (COS) has a list of journals that accept registered reports.
- Check the COS website or similar resources for updated lists.
- Evaluate Journal Fit:
- Ensure that the journal's scope and focus align with your research topic.
- Consider the journal's impact factor, readership, and peer-review process.
- Look at past issues to see if the journal has published similar studies.
- Contact Journal Editors:
- If you are unsure whether a journal accepts registered reports, contact the editorial office directly.
- Ask about their policies and any specific requirements for registered reports.
- Compare Options:
- Compare the journals based on factors such as acceptance rates, turnaround times, and any associated costs.
- Choose the journal that best fits your research goals and timeline.
Example Journals that Accept Registered Reports:
- PLOS ONE
- Nature Human Behaviour
- Royal Society Open Science
- BMC Psychology
- Cortex
- Perspectives on Psychological Science
Additional Tips:
- Read Published Registered Reports:
- Reviewing published registered reports in your chosen journal can give you a better understanding of the format and expectations.
- Follow Guidelines:
- Carefully follow the journal's guidelines for registered reports. This often includes submitting a detailed study protocol and analysis plan before data collection.
- Seek Feedback:
- Consider seeking feedback from colleagues or mentors who have experience with registered reports.
By following these steps, you can effectively choose a journal that accepts registered reports and ensure that your submission meets all the necessary criteria. Good luck with your registered report!
💡 Try this comparison yourself:Compare AI models side-by-side on SNEOS
Analysis
This comparison demonstrates the different approaches each AI model takes when responding to the same prompt. Here are the key differences observed:
Response Characteristics
Grok: Provides a direct response with 48 sentences.
Mistral: Provides a direct response with 30 sentences.
Key Takeaways
- Each model brings unique strengths to this type of query
- Response styles vary significantly between models
- Consider your specific use case when choosing between these models
Try This Comparison Yourself
Want to test these models with your own prompts? Visit SNEOS.com to compare AI responses side-by-side in real-time.
This comparison was generated using the SNEOS AI Comparison ToolPublished: October 15, 2025 | Models: Grok, Mistral