ChatGPT vs DeepSeek vs Grok: DNA Discovery

Prompt
DNA structure discovery - Watson, Crick, Franklin, Wilkins
ChatGPTOpenAI
DNA structure discovery - Watson, Crick, Franklin, Wilkins

The discovery of the DNA structure is a landmark achievement in the field of molecular biology. It primarily involved the contributions of James Watson, Francis Crick, Rosalind Franklin, and Maurice Wilkins.

Key Contributors and Their Roles:


  • James Watson and Francis Crick:

  • In 1953, Watson and Crick proposed the double helix model of DNA.

  • They used existing data, including X-ray diffraction images, to develop a 3D model showing DNA as two strands twisted around each other.

  • Their model explained how genetic information is stored and replicated.

  • Rosalind Franklin:

  • Franklin was an expert in X-ray crystallography.

  • She produced high-quality X-ray diffraction images of DNA, most notably Photograph 51.

  • Her work provided critical evidence of the helical structure and dimensions of DNA.

  • Unfortunately, her contribution was not fully recognized during her lifetime.

  • Maurice Wilkins:

  • Wilkins was Franklin's colleague at King’s College London.

  • He also worked with X-ray diffraction of DNA and shared Franklin’s data with Watson and Crick (with some controversy).

  • Wilkins' work helped corroborate the helical structure of DNA.


Timeline Summary:


  • Early 1950s: Franklin and Wilkins gather X-ray diffraction images.

  • 1953: Watson and Crick build the double helix model.

  • 1962: Watson, Crick, and Wilkins receive the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for their work on DNA. Franklin had passed away in 1958 and was not eligible for the Nobel (which is not awarded posthumously).


Importance:


  • The double helix model explained DNA replication and genetic encoding.

  • It laid the foundation for modern genetics and biotechnology.


If you want, I can provide more detailed information on any of these scientists or the discovery process!

11:21
DeepSeekDeepSeek
DNA structure discovery - Watson, Crick, Franklin, Wilkins

Of course. The story of the discovery of the DNA double helix is a classic tale of scientific ingenuity, collaboration, rivalry, and, until recently, often overlooked contribution.

Here is a breakdown of the key figures and the narrative of the discovery.

The Core Quartet


  • James Watson (American Biologist): A young, ambitious, and brilliant scientist who was convinced that understanding the structure of DNA was the key to understanding genetics.

  • **Francis Crick (British Physicist):* A talkative, theoretically-minded physicist with a deep understanding of X-ray crystallography and model-building. He and Watson formed a perfect intellectual partnership at the Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge.

  • Rosalind Franklin (British Chemist): An expert in X-ray crystallography, working at King's College London. She was meticulous, rigorous, and produced the highest-quality images of DNA fibers. Her famous Photo 51 was critical evidence.

  • Maurice Wilkins (British Physicist): Also at King's College London, he was the deputy director of the lab where Franklin worked. A miscommunication led him to believe Franklin was his assistant, creating a tense and unproductive relationship. It was Wilkins who, without Franklin's knowledge, showed Photo 51 to Watson.



The Narrative of the Discovery

The race to discover the structure of DNA in the early 1950s was intense, with several world-class labs competing, most notably Linus Pauling's group at Caltech.

The Work at King's College London (Franklin & Wilkins)


  • Rosalind Franklin's Role: Franklin was the experimental expert. She perfected the technique for creating fine DNA fibers and capturing their X-ray diffraction patterns. Her data, which she interpreted with great skill, clearly indicated:

  • That DNA had a helical structure.

  • The sugar-phosphate backbone was on the outside of the molecule.

  • There were two forms of DNA: a dry "A" form and a wet "B" form. Photo 51 was of the "B" form, which more clearly revealed the helical pattern.

  • Maurice Wilkins' Role: Wilkins was also working on DNA but was more cautious and less advanced in his crystallography than Franklin. The poor relationship between them meant they did not collaborate effectively.


The Work at Cambridge (Watson & Crick)


  • Initial, Failed Attempt: Watson and Crick built an initial triple-helix model with the backbone on the inside. When they invited Franklin to see it, she immediately pointed out its flaws, noting that her data showed the backbone was unequivocally on the outside. This public humiliation led their boss, William Bragg, to tell them to leave DNA to the King's team.

  • The Critical "Data Sharing": In January 1953, Wilkins, feeling frustrated with the stalemate at King's, showed Watson Franklin's famous Photo 51. Watson, upon seeing it, immediately recognized the signature of a helix. As he later wrote, "My mouth fell open and my pulse began to race."

  • The Final Push: Later, Watson and Crick were given access to a King's College report to the Medical Research Council (MRC) which included a summary of Franklin's unpublished data. This data provided crucial, precise measurements about the density, water content, and symmetry (a key point) of the DNA crystal.

  • The "Eureka" Moment: Crick, a trained physicist, realized that Franklin's data indicated that the molecule was symmetrical, meaning the two strands ran in opposite directions (anti-parallel). This was a vital insight. Meanwhile, Watson worked on figuring out how the bases (A, T, G, C) paired together in the middle. He eventually discovered that Adenine (A) always pairs with Thymine (T), and Guanine (G) always pairs with Cytosine (C), using hydrogen bonds. This "complementary base pairing" explained both the constant width of the molecule and how genetic information could be copied.


The Publication and Aftermath

On April 25, 1953, Watson and Crick published their seminal one-page paper, "Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid," in the journal Nature. In a classic example of British understatement, they included one of the most famous lines in science: "It has not escaped our notice that the specific pairing we have postulated immediately suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material."

In the same issue of Nature, two accompanying papers from King's College were published: one by Franklin and her student Raymond Gosling, which included Photo 51 and provided the experimental support for the model, and one by Wilkins and colleagues.


The Nobel Prize and the "Dark Lady" of DNA


  • In 1962, the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine was awarded to James Watson, Francis Crick, and Maurice Wilkins.

  • Rosalind Franklin was not included. Nobel Prizes are not awarded posthumously, and she had died of ovarian cancer in 1958 at the age of 37. The extent of her contribution only became widely known to the public after Watson's 1968 book, The Double Helix, which portrayed her in a less-than-flattering light (calling her "Rosy" and depicting her as difficult).

  • The debate continues to this day about whether she would have shared the prize had she lived. Most historians of science now agree that her data was not just "shown" to Watson and Crick, but was essential to their success. She was on the verge of solving the structure herself but was more focused on collecting perfect data than on speculative model-building.


Summary of Key Contributions

FigurePrimary Contribution
Watson & CrickSynthesized the available data (from Chargaff, Pauling, and Franklin) to build the final, correct theoretical model of the double helix, including the concept of complementary base pairing.
Rosalind FranklinProduced the crucial experimental evidence (X-ray diffraction patterns, especially Photo 51) that revealed the helix's key parameters: its dimensions, symmetry, and the location of the backbone.
Maurice WilkinsInitiated the X-ray diffraction work on DNA at King's College and, controversially, shared Franklin's critical data with Watson, which accelerated the final discovery.

The discovery of the DNA double helix is a powerful reminder that science is a human endeavor, driven by a mix of collaboration, competition, personality clashes, and the sometimes-uneven distribution of credit.

11:21
GrokxAI
DNA structure discovery - Watson, Crick, Franklin, Wilkins

The discovery of the structure of DNA, a fundamental breakthrough in biology, was the result of collaborative and competitive scientific efforts in the early 1950s. The key figures involved were James Watson, Francis Crick, Rosalind Franklin, and Maurice Wilkins. Their work culminated in the identification of the double-helix structure of DNA, which revolutionized our understanding of genetics and heredity. Below is an overview of their contributions and the context of the discovery.


Background


DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) was known to be the molecule carrying genetic information, but its structure—and how it could store and replicate this information—was a mystery. By the early 1950s, scientists were racing to determine its molecular structure. The discovery was made possible by advancements in X-ray crystallography, a technique used to analyze the arrangement of atoms in a molecule.


Key Figures and Contributions


  • James Watson (1928–present)

  • An American molecular biologist, Watson was a young postdoctoral researcher when he joined the Cavendish Laboratory at the University of Cambridge in 1951.

  • Watson was determined to uncover the structure of DNA and collaborated closely with Francis Crick.

  • He brought knowledge of genetics and an enthusiasm for model-building to the partnership.

  • Watson is often credited with recognizing the significance of base-pairing (A-T and G-C) in DNA, which was critical to understanding how the molecule could replicate.

  • Francis Crick (1916–2004)

  • A British physicist and molecular biologist, Crick was working at the Cavendish Laboratory under Max Perutz.

  • With a background in physics, Crick contributed a rigorous theoretical approach to the problem.

  • He and Watson built physical models to test possible structures of DNA, eventually arriving at the double-helix model.

  • Crick also played a key role in interpreting the X-ray diffraction data and understanding the implications of the structure for genetic replication.

  • Rosalind Franklin (1920–1958)

  • A British chemist and X-ray crystallographer, Franklin worked at King’s College London under Maurice Wilkins.

  • Franklin produced high-quality X-ray diffraction images of DNA, notably "Photograph 51," which provided critical evidence of the helical structure of DNA.

  • Her precise measurements of the DNA molecule’s dimensions and her deduction that the phosphates were on the outside of the structure were essential for Watson and Crick’s model.

  • Franklin’s work was shared with Watson and Crick (some argue without her full consent), and though she was close to solving the structure herself, she did not receive adequate recognition during her lifetime. Tragically, she died of ovarian cancer in 1958 at the age of 37, before the full impact of her contributions was widely acknowledged.

  • Maurice Wilkins (1916–2004)

  • A New Zealand-born British biophysicist, Wilkins also worked at King’s College London and was initially in charge of the DNA research project there.

  • He conducted early X-ray diffraction studies of DNA and collaborated with Franklin, though their relationship was strained due to interpersonal and professional differences.

  • Wilkins shared Franklin’s data, including Photograph 51, with Watson and Crick, which helped them build their model.

  • He continued to provide experimental support for the double-helix model after its proposal.



Timeline of the Discovery


  • Early 1950s: Scientists, including Linus Pauling in the U.S., were competing to solve the structure of DNA. Pauling proposed an incorrect triple-helix model in 1953, which spurred Watson and Crick to intensify their efforts.

  • 1951–1952: Franklin and Wilkins worked on X-ray diffraction at King’s College, producing crucial images and measurements of DNA.

  • Early 1953: Watson saw Franklin’s Photograph 51 (via Wilkins) and recognized the helical nature of DNA. Combined with Franklin’s data on the molecule’s dimensions, Watson and Crick built a model of DNA as a double helix with complementary base-pairing.

  • April 25, 1953: Watson and Crick published their landmark paper in Nature, titled "Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid," describing the double-helix structure. In the same issue, papers by Franklin and Wilkins provided supporting X-ray data.



The Double-Helix Model


The structure proposed by Watson and Crick revealed that DNA consists of two strands twisted into a double helix, resembling a spiral staircase. Key features include:
  • The backbone of each strand is made of sugar and phosphate groups.

  • The strands are connected by base pairs (adenine-thymine [A-T] and guanine-cytosine [G-C]) held together by hydrogen bonds.

  • The complementary base-pairing explained how DNA could replicate by unzipping and serving as a template for new strands.


This model not only explained DNA’s structure but also provided the mechanism for genetic inheritance and replication, laying the foundation for modern molecular biology.


Recognition and Controversy


  • Nobel Prize: In 1962, Watson, Crick, and Wilkins were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for their discoveries concerning the molecular structure of nucleic acids. Franklin was not included, as Nobel Prizes are not awarded posthumously, and her critical contributions were less recognized at the time.

  • Franklin’s Recognition: Over time, historians and scientists have emphasized Franklin’s pivotal role. Many argue that she was unfairly overlooked due to gender bias in science at the time and the circumstances surrounding the sharing of her data.



Legacy


The discovery of the DNA double helix marked the beginning of the molecular biology revolution. It led to advancements in genetics, biotechnology, and medicine, including the Human Genome Project and gene-editing technologies like CRISPR. The story of Watson, Crick, Franklin, and Wilkins also serves as a reminder of the importance of collaboration, ethics, and equity in scientific research.

If you’d like to dive deeper into specific aspects, such as Franklin’s contributions or the ethical debates surrounding the discovery, let me know!

11:21

Analysis

This comparison demonstrates the different approaches each AI model takes when responding to the same prompt. Here are the key differences observed:

Response Characteristics

ChatGPT: Provides a direct response with 22 sentences.

DeepSeek: Provides a detailed response with 52 sentences.

Grok: Provides a detailed response with 50 sentences.

Key Takeaways

  • Each model brings unique strengths to this type of query
  • Response styles vary significantly between models
  • Consider your specific use case when choosing between these models

Try This Comparison Yourself

Want to test these models with your own prompts? Visit SNEOS.com to compare AI responses side-by-side in real-time.


This comparison was generated using the SNEOS AI Comparison ToolPublished: October 01, 2025 | Models: ChatGPT, DeepSeek, Grok