Of course. Here is a comprehensive comparison of popular payment gateways to help you choose the right one for your business.

This guide breaks down the key players based on business size, model, and specific needs.

Quick Comparison Table

Feature	Stripe	PayPal	Square	Authorize.Net	Adyen
Best For	Developers, online businesses, subscriptions	New businesses, freelancers, global brand recognition	In-person/retail, omnichannel simplicity	Businesses already with a merchant account	Large enterprises, global sales
Pricing Model	Pay-as-you-go	Pay-as-you-go	Pay-as-you-go	Monthly fee + pay-as-you-go	Custom/Volume-based
Transaction Fee	2.9% + $0.30 (online)	2.99% + $0.49 (standard)	2.6% + $0.10 (in-person)	2.9% + $0.30 (gateway fee only)	Custom (typically lower)
Monthly Fee	$0	$0 (Optional $30 for Virtual Terminal)	$0	$25	Custom (often high)
Setup Fee	$0	$0	$0	$0	Custom
Key Strength	Powerful API, customization, global reach	Trusted brand, easy setup, wide user adoption	All-in-one ecosystem, hardware integration	Long-standing reliability, extensive features	Unified commerce, 250+ payment methods
Key Weakness	Less "out-of-the-box" for non-devs	Can be costly, account holds/freezes	Less customizable for complex online needs	Can be more expensive for small volume	Not for small businesses

---

In-Depth Gateway Breakdown

1. Stripe

Stripe is the developer's favorite, known for its powerful and flexible API.

• Pros:


• Excellent Developer Experience: Incredibly well-documented API for fully custom payment integrations.


• Global Scale: Supports 135+ currencies and numerous local payment methods (like iDEAL, SEPA).


• Rich Feature Set: Built-in tools for subscriptions, invoicing, fraud prevention (Radar), and more.


• Transparent Pricing: No monthly fees or hidden costs for standard accounts.


• Cons:


• Requires Technical Skill: Not the best "out-of-the-box" solution for non-technical users.


• Customer Support: Primarily email-based; phone support is limited.


• Ideal for: Tech-savvy businesses, SaaS companies, marketplaces, subscription services, and international e-commerce.

2. PayPal

PayPal is the most recognized name in online payments, offering trust and simplicity.

• Pros:


• Consumer Trust: Over 400 million active accounts; customers feel safe checking out with PayPal.


• Extremely Easy Setup: "Pay with PayPal" button can be added to a site in minutes.


• Wide Acceptance: Accepted by nearly every e-commerce platform.


• Multiple Products: Includes PayPal Checkout, Venmo, PayPal Credit, and Braintree (a developer-centric gateway).


• Cons:


• Higher Fees: Can be more expensive than competitors, especially for micro-transactions.


• Account Stability: Known for occasionally freezing funds and accounts for review.


• User Experience: Can redirect customers away from your site to complete payment.


• Ideal for: New businesses, freelancers, B2C e-commerce, and any business that benefits from the PayPal brand.

3. Square

Square started with in-person payments and has built a full ecosystem around it.

• Pros:


• All-in-One Ecosystem: Seamlessly integrates POS, hardware, payroll, invoices, and online stores.


• Excellent for In-Person Sales: Simple, transparent pricing for card-present transactions.


• User-Friendly: Very easy to set up and use with minimal technical knowledge.


• Free Online Store: Offers a basic online storefront for free.


• Cons:


• Online-Only Rates: Higher than some competitors for e-commerce (2.9% + $0.30).


• Less Customizable: Not as developer-friendly as Stripe for complex integrations.


• Ideal for: Retail stores, restaurants, service-based businesses, and small businesses wanting a unified system.

4. Authorize.Net

A long-standing, reliable gateway that is often offered by banks and merchant account providers.

• Pros:


• Reliability & Stability: One of the oldest players, known for its uptime and security.


• Extensive Features: Includes a virtual terminal, recurring billing, and advanced fraud detection.


• Wide Integration: Works with almost every shopping cart and merchant account.


• Cons:


• Cost Structure: Requires a monthly gateway fee ($25) on top of transaction fees, making it expensive for low-volume businesses.


• Older Interface: The user experience can feel dated compared to modern competitors.


• Ideal for: Established small-to-medium businesses that already have a merchant account and value reliability over the lowest cost.

5. Adyen

A global enterprise-grade payments platform that powers companies like Uber, Spotify, and eBay.

• Pros:


• Unified Commerce: Single platform to process online, in-app, and in-store payments.


• Global Reach: Supports a vast number of local currencies and payment methods worldwide.


• Optimized Checkout: Data-driven tools to increase conversion rates.


• Interchange++ Pricing: Most transparent and often cheapest pricing model for high volume.


• Cons:


• Not for SMBs: Has a high barrier to entry, often requiring significant monthly processing volume.


• Custom Pricing: You must contact sales for a quote.


• Ideal for: Large enterprises, international brands, and businesses with complex, high-volume payment needs.

---

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing

• Your Business Model:


• Online-Only: Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.Net.


• In-Person/Retail: Square is the leader.


• Both (Omnichannel): Square, Stripe, Adyen.


• Subscriptions/SaaS: Stripe is the gold standard.


• Technical Expertise:


• High (You have developers): Stripe, Braintree.


• Low (You want simplicity): Square, PayPal Standard.


• Pricing Structure:


• Pay-as-you-go (No monthly fee): Best for new or low-volume businesses (Stripe, PayPal, Square).


• Flat-rate + Monthly fee: Can be cheaper for high-volume businesses (Authorize.Net, traditional merchant accounts).


• Sales Volume:


• Low to Medium: Stick with pay-as-you-go providers.


• High Volume ($10k+/month): Negotiate custom rates with Stripe, or look at interchange-plus pricing from providers like Adyen or traditional merchant accounts.


• International Sales:


• Must-Haves: Multi-currency support, local payment methods (e.g., iDEAL in Netherlands, Alipay in China).


• Best Options: Stripe, Adyen, PayPal.

Final Recommendation

• For most new online businesses: Start with Stripe or PayPal. They are easy to integrate via platforms like Shopify or WooCommerce and have no monthly fees.


• For a physical store or mobile services: Square is the easiest and most cost-effective starting point.


• For a tech-heavy business or subscriptions: Stripe is almost always the best choice.


• For large, global enterprises: Adyen is the platform to evaluate for its unified commerce and global capabilities.

Next Step: Most providers offer sandbox/test modes. Create a free account with your top 2-3 choices and try their dashboard and integration process to see which feels right for you.