Private messaging apps vary widely in terms of security, features, user base, and ease of use. Below is a comparison of some of the most popular private messaging apps based on key criteria like encryption, privacy policies, features, and platform availability. This comparison includes Signal, WhatsApp, Telegram, iMessage, and Threema as of late 2023.

---

1. Signal

• Encryption: End-to-end encryption (E2EE) for all messages, calls, and group chats by default. Open-source protocol (Signal Protocol), widely regarded as the gold standard for security.


• Privacy: Collects minimal data (only phone number for registration). No ads, no trackers. Open-source code allows independent security audits.


• Ownership: Non-profit (Signal Foundation), focused on privacy rather than profit.


• Features:


• Disappearing messages.


• Secure voice and video calls.


• Group chats with E2EE.


• Ability to blur faces in photos before sending.


• No cloud backups unless manually enabled with a PIN.


• Platforms: iOS, Android, Desktop (linked to mobile).


• User Base: Smaller compared to WhatsApp or Telegram, but growing among privacy-conscious users.


• Pros:


• Best-in-class security and privacy.


• No corporate ownership or data monetization.


• Cons:


• Smaller user base; not everyone you know may use it.


• Requires a phone number for registration.

---

2. WhatsApp

• Encryption: End-to-end encryption for all messages, calls, and media (based on Signal Protocol) by default since 2016.


• Privacy: Owned by Meta (Facebook), which raises concerns about metadata collection. While message content is encrypted, Meta collects data like contacts, usage patterns, and device info for advertising purposes (outside the EU in some cases). EU users are better protected under GDPR.


• Ownership: Meta (Facebook), a for-profit company with a history of privacy scandals.


• Features:


• Disappearing messages.


• Secure voice, video, and group calls.


• Cloud backups (encrypted since 2021, but tied to Google Drive or iCloud, which may not be as secure).


• Large group support (up to 1,024 participants).


• Platforms: iOS, Android, Desktop (linked to mobile).


• User Base: Massive (over 2 billion users), widely used globally.


• Pros:


• Huge user base, almost universally adopted.


• E2EE for all communications.


• Cons:


• Owned by Meta, which may use metadata for other purposes.


• Privacy policy is less transparent compared to Signal.

---

3. Telegram

• Encryption: End-to-end encryption only for Secret Chats (one-on-one). Regular chats and group chats are not E2EE by default; data is stored on Telegram’s servers with server-side encryption.


• Privacy: Collects more data than Signal (e.g., phone number, contacts, usage data). Cloud-based storage means Telegram has access to non-E2EE chat data. Offers some privacy controls (e.g., hiding phone number).


• Ownership: Independent, founded by Pavel Durov, but funded through unclear means (recently introduced ads for revenue).


• Features:


• Large groups (up to 200,000 members) and channels for broadcasts.


• Bots and customization options.


• Cloud storage for messages (accessible across devices).


• Disappearing messages (only in Secret Chats).


• Platforms: iOS, Android, Desktop (independent of mobile).


• User Base: Large (over 700 million users), popular for group communication.


• Pros:


• Feature-rich with massive group support.


• Cloud syncing across devices.


• Cons:


• E2EE not enabled by default; most chats are not fully private.


• Server-side storage raises privacy concerns.

---

4. iMessage (Apple)

• Encryption: End-to-end encryption by default for messages sent between Apple devices. Messages to non-Apple users (SMS/MMS) are not encrypted.


• Privacy: Apple claims to prioritize privacy, collecting minimal data compared to Meta or Google. However, messages are backed up to iCloud by default (unless backups are disabled or encrypted), which could be accessed if iCloud security is compromised. Apple has faced scrutiny for potential government backdoors.


• Ownership: Apple, a for-profit company, though privacy is a key marketing point.


• Features:


• Integration with Apple ecosystem (iPhone, iPad, Mac).


• Rich media support, animated effects, and apps.


• Disappearing messages not supported.


• Platforms: iOS, macOS (exclusive to Apple devices).


• User Base: Huge among Apple users, especially in the US.


• Pros:


• Seamless for Apple users.


• Strong E2EE when messaging other Apple devices.


• Cons:


• Not cross-platform (no Android support).


• No E2EE for SMS or if chatting with non-Apple users.


• iCloud backups could be a vulnerability.

---

5. Threema

• Encryption: End-to-end encryption for all messages, calls, and group chats by default. Uses open-source NaCl cryptography library.


• Privacy: Does not require a phone number or email for registration (unique ID system). Minimal data collection. Servers are hosted in Switzerland, which has strong privacy laws.


• Ownership: Independent Swiss company, focused on privacy.


• Features:


• Disappearing messages not supported.


• Secure calls and group chats.


• No cloud backups (messages stored locally).


• Polls and file sharing.


• Platforms: iOS, Android, Desktop (linked to mobile).


• User Base: Smaller, niche user base, mostly in Europe.


• Pros:


• High privacy with no phone number requirement.


• Strong encryption and Swiss privacy laws.


• Cons:


• Smaller user base.


• One-time purchase cost (~$5), not free.


• Fewer features compared to WhatsApp or Telegram.

---

Summary Table

App	E2EE by Default	Privacy Level	Ownership	User Base	Platforms	Cost
Signal	Yes (all chats)	Very High	Non-profit	Medium	iOS, Android, Desktop	Free
WhatsApp	Yes (all chats)	Moderate (Meta)	Meta (Facebook)	Very Large	iOS, Android, Desktop	Free
Telegram	No (Secret Chats only)	Moderate	Independent	Large	iOS, Android, Desktop	Free
iMessage	Yes (Apple-to-Apple)	High (Apple)	Apple	Large (Apple users)	iOS, macOS	Free
Threema	Yes (all chats)	Very High	Independent (Swiss)	Small	iOS, Android, Desktop	~$5 (one-time)

---

Which App Should You Choose?

• Best for Privacy and Security: Signal or Threema. Signal is free and widely recommended by security experts. Threema offers similar privacy with the added benefit of no phone number requirement but at a small cost.


• Best for Mass Adoption: WhatsApp. It’s the most widely used globally, ensuring you can reach almost anyone, though privacy concerns with Meta persist.


• Best for Groups and Features: Telegram. Great for large communities and cloud syncing, but weak on default privacy.


• Best for Apple Users: iMessage. Seamless within the Apple ecosystem, but useless for cross-platform communication.


• Best for Anonymity: Threema. No personal info required to sign up.

Each app has trade-offs between privacy, features, and accessibility. If privacy is your top concern, prioritize Signal or Threema. If you need to communicate with a wide audience, WhatsApp or Telegram might be more practical. Always consider your specific needs, the people you communicate with, and the level of trust you place in the app’s ownership and policies.